Skip over main navigation
  • Sign up
  • Log in
  • Basket: (0 items)
  • Shop
  • Accessibility
  • Contact Us
  • Sign up to our e-News
British Institute of Human Rights
Human Rights Act Review Get our resources Donate
  • Twitter
Menu
  • HUMAN RIGHTS INFO
    • Human Rights Info Hub
    • News
    • Blog
  • Our Impact Stories
    • Changing Lives
    • Transforming Organisations
  • Our Work
    • Our Work
      • Our work with People
      • Our work with Communities
      • Our work with Public Bodies & Services
      • Our work on Policy Change
    • HUMAN RIGHTS: Issues We Address
    • FOCUS: Reviews of the Human Rights Act
    • FOCUS: Human Rights Day 2020
    • Events & Trainings
  • ABOUT BIHR
    • About us
      • Our Mission, Vision & Aims
      • What we do
    • Our People
      • Our Trustee Board
      • Our Staff Team
      • Join Our Team
      • Intern Alumni
    • Our Funding
      • Trusts, Foundations and Grants
      • Contracts, Commissions & Clients
      • Relationship with QMUL
    • Why Human Rights?
    • Get in touch
      • Contact Us
      • Get Help
  • SUPPORT US
    • Support BIHR
      • Donate
      • Become a Friend of BIHR
    • Stay Informed
  • Coronavirus
  • Admin
    • Log in
    • Shop
    • Accessibility
    • Contact Us
    • Sign up to our e-News
  • Basket: (0 items)
  • C. The European Court of Human Rights
  1. HUMAN RIGHTS INFO
  2. Past, Present and Future
  3. Human Rights Law Explained

C. The European Court of Human Rights

What is the Court?

The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) is an international court set up in 1959 which oversees the implementation of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) 1950. Find out more about the ECHR here.

Who does it protect?

The ECtHR is based in Strasbourg, France, where it monitors respect for the human rights of the 820 million people in the 47 member states of the Council of Europe that have agreed to abide by the ECHR.

How does it work?

The ECtHR rules on applications by individuals alleging that officials within their country have violated their rights in the ECHR. It is important to remember that applying to the ECtHR does not mean the issue will become a legal case; many are not admissible (this could be because the right process is not followed or because the case does not actually raise human rights issues).

The judgments of the ECtHR are legally binding. This means countries must implement the rulings; to not do so means not following the international rule of law.

How does it remain relevant?

Cases in the ECtHR’ help ensure the ECHR is a ‘living instrument’ able to remain relevant to today’s society and not stuck in the 1950s when the protections were written down. For example, the idea of family in 1950 was very different to modern understanding and the right to respect for family and private life (Article 8) now recognises unmarried couples, same-sex couples, single-parents and their children.

Impact in the UK

Five examples of how the ECtHR has improve protection of our rights in the UK:

An antique dealer’s phone was tapped when he was wrongly suspected of handling stolen goods. The Court found that the lack of any legal regulation of state interceptions of communications breached the right to respect for private life (Article 8). This led to the UK’s first regulation of intercepting communications - the Interception of Communications Act 1985. (Malone v UK, 1984)

 Four children had been abused but social services took five years to take action, all efforts to hold authorities to account under English law failed. The Court ruled there was a positive obligation to protect the children from inhuman and degrading treatment (Article 3) and this had been breached. ( Z v UK, 2001)

The lack of legal recognition given to transsexual people was challenged and the Court found a breach of the right to family life (Article 8) and to marry (Article 12). This case (along with a domestic case under the Human Rights Act) led to legal recognition of gender reassignment for transsexual people. (Goodwin v UK 2002)

When an autistic man who lacked capacity to consent or object to medical treatment was kept in a psychiatric hospital without procedural safeguards to protect his rights, the Court found a breach of the right to liberty (Article 5). This led to the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards in the Mental Capacity Act 2005, designed to provide legal protections. (HL v UK, 2004)

An employer’s policy banning the wearing of a cross necklace for corporate image reasons was held to infringe rights to freedom of thought, conscience and religion (Article 9). (Eweida v UK, 2013) 

Impact in other countries

It is important to remember we are part of a wider system and the ECtHR provides important protections in other places. This includes:

  • Ireland decriminalised homosexual acts
  • The UK banned corporal punishment in schools
  • Belgium adopted measures to prohibit discrimination against children born outside marriage
  • Bulgaria created an alternative to military service for conscientious objectors
  • The Netherlands changed laws about detaining people with mental health problems
  • Russia improved the social welfare measures for the victims of Chernobyl
  • Slovenia made changes to help prevent ill-treatment by the police
  • Latvia abolished discriminatory language tests for candidates standing for election
  • Moldova recognised freedom of religion

 

 

Published: 25th September, 2014

Updated: 6th November, 2020

Author: Woody Faulkner

Related topics:
  • Human Rights The Law
Share this page
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Latest

  • Our Human Rights Upskilling Sessions

    Did you miss our HRA Upskilling Sessions? Find out more about the HRA Review and how to get involved.

  • Human Rights Weekly News 15-18 February 2021

    Human Rights Weekly News 15-18 February 2021

    Read a round-up of the weeks human rights news, from BIHR and elsewhere!

  • BIHR Explainer: The Mental Health Act White Paper and Consultation

    BIHR Explainer: The Mental Health Act White Paper and Consultation

    Learn more about the Mental Health Act White Paper and consultation.

  • Human Rights Weekly News 8-11 February 2021

    Human Rights Weekly News 8-11 February 2021

    Read a round-up of the weekly news - from BIHR and elsewhere!

Related

  • A. The Law: The Human Rights Act

    A. The Law: The Human Rights Act

    Find out about our law here at home, the Human Rights Act, and how it protects us all.

  • B. The European Convention on Human Rights

    B. The European Convention on Human Rights

    Find out about the European Convention on Human Rights and what it means for you.

Most read

  • A. The Law: The Human Rights Act

    A. The Law: The Human Rights Act

    Find out about our law here at home, the Human Rights Act, and how it protects us all.

  • Volunteer and Fundraise

    Volunteer and Fundraise

    volunteering opportunities

  • B. The European Convention on Human Rights

    B. The European Convention on Human Rights

    Find out about the European Convention on Human Rights and what it means for you.

  • The history of human rights

    Did you know the ideas behind human rights in the UK are over 800 years old? Read more about the journey behind the Human Rights Act.

  • I Need Help

    I Need Help

  • A Human Rights Approach to Advocacy

    A Human Rights Approach to Advocacy

    Care and Support: A Human Rights Approach to Advocacy

  • Midwifery and Human Rights: A Practitioner's Guide

    Midwifery and Human Rights: A Practitioner's Guide

    This Guide has been developed to support midwives to deliver maternity services that respect human rights.

  • Mental Health Advocacy and Human Rights: Your Guide

    Mental Health Advocacy and Human Rights: Your Guide

    Co-produced with advocacy groups this guide shows how the rights and duties in the Human Rights Act can help strengthen support for people with mental health problems. It uses handy tables, flowcharts, case studies, and worked through examples.

  • About us

    About us

  • Human Rights Training

    Human Rights Training

    Find out more about BIHR's market-leading human rights training services.

Tag cloud

capacity dignity European Convention on Human Rights General Election 2017 Government health Health and Human Rights Health and Social Care Healthcare human rights Human Rights Act International human rights Justice Mental Health older people social care

Latest tweet

Keep in touch

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER LIKE US ON FACEBOOK WATCH US ON YOUTUBE

Helpful Links

  • My Human Rights
  • Human Rights Training
  • Health & Human Rights Hub
  • Act for UK Rights Blog
  • Become a Friend of BIHR

Please note the British Institute of Human Rights does not provide advice, help can be found here

Our office can be contacted on 0207 882 5850
For press enquiries please call 0207 882 5850 or email [email protected]

EMAIL US

The British Institute of Human Rights is a registered charity (1101575) and registered company (4978121)

Registered office: School of Law, Queen Mary, University of London, Mile End Road, London E1 4NS