Skip over main navigation
  • Log in
  • Basket: (0 items)
  • Shop
  • Accessibility
  • Contact Us
  • Sign up to our e-News
British Institute of Human Rights
Get our training Get our resources Donate
  • Twitter
Menu
  • HUMAN RIGHTS INFO
    • The Human Rights Act
    • What Rights Do I Have?
    • Human Rights Info Hub
    • Human Rights Act Reform
    • Easy Read Human Rights Info
    • News
    • Explainers
    • Blog
    • Why our Human Rights Act Matters Blog
  • Our Impact
    • Our Impact
    • Transforming Organisations
    • Changing Lives
  • Our Work
    • Our Work
      • Our work with People
      • Our work with Communities
      • Our work with Public Bodies & Services
      • Our work on Policy Change
      • Joint Letters and Campaigns
    • BIHR & NHSE CAMHS Human Rights Programme
    • BIHR's Project on Government Consultations and Human Rights
    • FOCUS: Human Rights Day 2021
    • HUMAN RIGHTS: Issues We Address
    • FOCUS: Surveillance and Human Rights
    • FOCUS: Reviews of the Human Rights Act
    • FOCUS: DNAR Decision-Making in 2020
    • FOCUS: The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights
    • FOCUS:The Mental Heath Act Reform and Human Rights
    • FOCUS: Co-design a human rights support “solution"
    • FOCUS: Social Care Reforms Analysis
    • Events & Trainings
    • BIHR's Communites of Practice
  • ABOUT BIHR
    • About us
      • Our Mission, Vision & Aims
      • What we do
    • Our People
      • Our Trustee Board
      • Our Staff Team
      • Opportunities With Us
    • Our Funding
      • Trusts, Foundations and Grants
      • Contracts, Commissions & Clients
    • Why Human Rights?
    • Get in touch
      • Contact Us
      • BIHR's Communites of Practice
      • Get Help
  • SUPPORT US
    • Support BIHR
      • Donate
      • Become a Friend of BIHR
    • Stay Informed
      • Stay Informed
      • Sign up to our eNews
      • BIHR's Communites of Practice
  • Rights Removal Bill
  • Admin
    • Log in
    • Shop
    • Accessibility
    • Contact Us
    • Sign up to our e-News
  • Basket: (0 items)
  • DNAR Decision-Making
  1. Our Work
  2. Our Work

DNAR Decision-Making

Find out about our work on DNAR decision-making. Our research during the pandemic has centred the experience and rights of people and staff, and helped to inform the work of the Care Quality Commission on this issue. Our research has been reported in the UK press, informing national conversations on this issue - see the end of this page. 

We are continuing our work on this issue by supporting the Stop People Dying Too Young group. The group is made up of self advocates and family carers working in the North East on Leder – the learning from lives and death programme. The group represents the interests of people with a learning disability, autistic people, and families. We are supporting the group's call to the Government to make sure that people with lived experience are represented on the Ministerial Oversight Group on DNAR, which was set up after the CQC review (see below for information on the CQC review). More detail on our work with the Stop People Dying Too Young group can be found here or scroll to the end of this webpage. 

What is a DNAR?

A Do Not Attempt Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation Order (DNACPR / DNR / DNAR) is when medical professionals decide to not provide CPR (cardiopulmonary resuscitation). CPR can be a life-saving treatment, depending on the situation; but it is also an invasive treatment and is not always successful. DNAR decisions are medical decisions. Often, these decisions will take place as part of advance care planning to allow people to decide that they do not want CPR in certain situations. It can also be discussed with people as part of their treatment plan, where medics do not think CPR would be beneficial, for example because someone is at the end of their life.

DNARs and people's human rights

When DNAR orders are made with the full involvement of a person, as part of advanced care planning or a treatment plan, this can be an example of good human rights practice. The use of DNARs orders without involving the person and/or their loved ones raises a number of human rights issues including: the right to life, the right to be free from inhuman and degrading treatment, the right to family and private life and the right to be free from discrimination, all of which must be respected and protected by health services under the Human Rights Act.

Highlighted during Covid-19 but a long-term issue

Each year people who draw on health and care services, advocates and frontline staff, share their concerns with us about DNARs being used a discriminatory or other improper ways. Since the start of Covid-19 pandemic in the UK (March 2020), there has been increasing concern about the use of DNAR orders being made without involving people, and that they are being made for discriminatory reasons, including because of people's age or because they are disabled (or both).

Read our Director's blog "The fight against Covid-19: Whose Life Counts?" from 2 April 2020. You can read more about the media coverage of issues we've raised on this at the end of this webpage. 

Through our direct work with over 2000 people during the pandemic, it became clear that DNAR decisions were continuing and a spotlight has been shone on this worrying, and often unlawful, practice. Our summer research showed (click on each image for the related research report)

      

The CQC DNAR Review and BIHR's work

We shared our research with the regulator in England, the Care Quality Commission. The CQC is conducting a rapid review of DNAR decisions during Covid-19 between November 2020 and March 2021 (CQC Press Release). We are a member of the CQC Expert Reference Group, sharing our concerns about the use of DNARs. To coincide with the Review, we have undertaken a programme of work to produce experience-led research on the use of DNARs with people drawing on services and those who care about them, advocates and staff in health, care and social work services. We have:

Research Workshops and surveys

Together with Learning Disability England and Turning point, we've hosted information and research workshops with people who have experienced DNAR decisions and their advocates, and staff working in health, care and social work who have seen the use of DNAR which they are concerned about. We also hosted open access, Easy Read, surveys with the same research questions to combine our findings. We research over 120 people directly in the research (although many shared the experiences of their groups, networks and colleagues), our staff workshop in particular was hugely over-subscribed, with a large waiting list. 

Our Reports

We have produced reports based on each workshop, publishing them after each session and prior to the CQC's final report. The Reports have been shared with the participants, the CQC and publicly. Both reports are also available in Easy Read versions:

People's experiences of DNARs when accessing health and social care: 

       

Staff experiences of DNARs when delivering health and care:  

     

 

2021: Supporting the campaign of the Stop People Dying Too Young group

The Stop People Dying Too Young group is made up of self advocates and family carers working in the North East on Leder – the learning from lives and death programme. The group represents the interests of people with a learning disability, autistic people, and families; it is supported by Inclusion North. Find out more about the group here. 

We are supporting campaign by the Stop People Dying Too Young to the UK Government about their actions on DNARs. We are doing this working alongside Inclusion North, Learning Disability England, Difference North East, and 80 other groups and individuals. 

The campaign is asking the Ministerial Oversight Group on Do Not Attempt Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation to involve people with lived experience in their work. The Ministerial Oversight Group was set up after the Care Quality Commission wrote a report called ‘Protect, Respect, Connect – decisions about living and dying well during Covid-19’. This report showed that during Covid-19 decisions about Do Not Resuscitate were made that were not in line with people’s human rights, including their rights to choices and be involved in decisions, and to not be discriminated against. Some people were affected more than others by this. People with a learning disability, older people and people with dementia were particularly affected.  Black, Asian and Minority

 Ethnic people were less likely to know that a Do Not Resuscitate decision had existed for them.

The Stop People Dying Too Young have co-produced a letter that to the Ministerial Oversight Group. You can read the letter here or click on the image below. Over 80 organisations have already signed the letter, showing this is an issue that lots of us have concerns about, to encourage the Group to listen and act. You can also add your name to it in support of what we are doing. If you want to support us by adding your name to the letter before 26 November 2021 you can sign here.

Blogs and media commentary on our work

  • Read our Director's blog "The fight against Covid-19: Whose Life Counts?" from 2 April 2020.
  • BBC Somerset Sound interview with our Director, Sanchita Hosali, on 8 April 2020 (Interview at 2:35.54)
  • "Social care staff not given human rights training to deal with Covid impact, finds research" Community Care, 4 December 2020, 8 September 2020
  • Read our Director's follow up blog "Still asking: Whose life counts in the fight against Covid-19?" from 3 December 2020
  • "'Unacceptable' do not resuscitate orders made in first Covid wave and some make still be in place, says CQC" Community Care, 4 December 2020
  • "NHS Doctors criticised over 'do not resuscitate' orders during pandemic", Financial Times, 1 March 2021
  • Watch our Director speak to the BBC as part of their coverage on unlawful DNAR decision-making and the CQC's new report - below. BBC News, 17 March 2021

Published: 23rd December, 2020

Updated: 4th November, 2021

Author: Josephine Whitehouse

Share this page
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Latest

  • Rights Removal Bill: Need to Know

    Rights Removal Bill: Need to Know

    Get guides on what the Government wants to change and what this could mean for all our rights.

  • Rights Removal Bill: How did we get here?

    Rights Removal Bill: How did we get here?

    From the Government ignoring the panel it commissioned to dismissing public opinions it asked for.

  • Weekly Human Rights News: 24/06/2022

    Weekly Human Rights News: 24/06/2022

    This week's human rights news is all about the Rights Removal Bill.

  • The Rights Removal Bill & Human Rights Act Reform

    The Rights Removal Bill & Human Rights Act Reform

    What is the Government's Rights Removal Bill, what does it mean and how can you take action?

Related

  • Amplifying the Voices of People with Lived Experience of Using the Human Rights Act

    Amplifying the Voices of People with Lived Experience of Using the Human Rights Act

    Amplifying the Voices of People with Lived Experience of Using the Human Rights Act

  • Campaigning on the Mental Capacity (Amendment) Act 2019

    Campaigning on the Mental Capacity (Amendment) Act 2019

    Read about the impact of our campaign to centre human rights in the Mental Capacity (Amendment) Act

  • The Independent Review of Administrative Law

    The Independent Review of Administrative Law

    Find out about our work and research on the judicial review process and human rights.

  • Coronavirus Act 2020: 6 Month Review

    Coronavirus Act 2020: 6 Month Review

    6 months of the Coronavirus Act: how the law is impacting people's human rights & our Calls to Action

  • Joint Committee on Human Rights Inquiry

    Joint Committee on Human Rights Inquiry

    Our evidence on the human rights implications of the UK Government's response to Covid-19.

Most read

  • The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide

    The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide

    The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide

  • A. The Law: The Human Rights Act

    A. The Law: The Human Rights Act

    Find out about our law here at home, the Human Rights Act, and how it protects us all.

  • Abolition of the Death Penalty

    Abolition of the Death Penalty

    Abolition of the Death Penalty

  • Social Justice and Human Rights

    Social Justice and Human Rights

    This World Social Justice Day we look at how we can use Human Rights to achieve positive social change.

  • The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide for staff working in public bodies

    The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide for staff working in public bodies

    Read our short guide for staff working in public bodies about the Covid-19 vaccine and human rights

  • What Rights Do I Have?

    What Rights Do I Have?

    What rights do I have?

  • B. The European Convention on Human Rights

    B. The European Convention on Human Rights

    Find out about the European Convention on Human Rights and what it means for you.

  • The Human Rights Act

    The Human Rights Act

    Find out more about the Human Rights Act, the main law that protects our human rights across the UK.

  • Volunteer and Fundraise

    Volunteer and Fundraise

    volunteering opportunities

  • The history of human rights

    Did you know the ideas behind human rights in the UK are over 800 years old? Read more about the journey behind the Human Rights Act.

Tag cloud

capacity dignity European Convention on Human Rights General Election 2017 Government health Health and Human Rights Health and Social Care Healthcare human rights Human Rights Act International human rights Justice Mental Health older people social care

Latest tweet

Keep in touch

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER LIKE US ON FACEBOOK WATCH US ON YOUTUBE

Helpful Links

  • My Human Rights
  • Human Rights Training
  • Easy Read Human Rights Info
  • BIHR Blog
  • Become a Friend of BIHR

Please note the British Institute of Human Rights does not provide advice, help can be found here

Our office can be contacted on 020 3039 3646
For press enquiries please call 020 3039 3646 or email [email protected]

EMAIL US

The British Institute of Human Rights is a registered charity (1101575) and registered company (4978121)

Correspondence and registered office address: BIHR, c/o Lewis & Co Chartered Accountants, 8 Coldbath Square, London, EC1R 5HL
Please note that we do not work at this address and the office here is not open to visitors; the address is for correspondence only.
Please therefore contact us by phone (020 3039 3646) if you wish to speak to us, but keep in mind that we do not provide advice;
help can be found here.