Skip over main navigation
  • Log in
  • Basket: (0 items)
  • Shop
  • Accessibility
  • Contact Us
  • Sign up to our e-News
British Institute of Human Rights
Get our resources Donate Get our training
  • Twitter
Menu
  • HUMAN RIGHTS INFO
    • The Human Rights Act
    • What Rights Do I Have?
    • Human Rights Info Hub
    • Human Rights Act Reform
    • Easy Read Human Rights Info
    • News
    • Explainers
    • Blog
    • Why our Human Rights Act Matters Blog
  • Our Impact
    • Our Impact
    • Transforming Organisations
    • Changing Lives
  • Our Work
    • Our Work
      • Our work with People
      • Our work with Communities
      • Our work with Public Bodies & Services
      • Our work on Policy Change
      • Joint Letters and Campaigns
    • BIHR & NHSE CAMHS Human Rights Programme
    • BIHR's Project on Government Consultations and Human Rights
    • FOCUS: Human Rights Day 2021
    • HUMAN RIGHTS: Issues We Address
    • FOCUS: Surveillance and Human Rights
    • FOCUS: Reviews of the Human Rights Act
    • FOCUS: DNAR Decision-Making in 2020
    • FOCUS: The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights
    • FOCUS:The Mental Heath Act Reform and Human Rights
    • FOCUS: Co-design a human rights support “solution"
    • FOCUS: Social Care Reforms Analysis
    • Events & Trainings
    • BIHR's Communites of Practice
  • ABOUT BIHR
    • About us
      • Our Mission, Vision & Aims
      • What we do
    • Our People
      • Our Trustee Board
      • Our Staff Team
      • Opportunities With Us
    • Our Funding
      • Trusts, Foundations and Grants
      • Contracts, Commissions & Clients
    • Why Human Rights?
    • Get in touch
      • Contact Us
      • BIHR's Communites of Practice
      • Get Help
  • SUPPORT US
    • Support BIHR
      • Donate
      • Become a Friend of BIHR
    • Stay Informed
      • Stay Informed
      • Sign up to our eNews
      • BIHR's Communites of Practice
  • Rights Removal Bill
  • Admin
    • Log in
    • Shop
    • Accessibility
    • Contact Us
    • Sign up to our e-News
  • Basket: (0 items)
  • iwd2015
  1. Blog

International Womens Day

The Human Rights Act, ensuring safety from domestic violence


By Natalie Threlfall (BIHR) and Tina Reece (Welsh Women's Aid)
 

Joanna Michael's Case

On the 5 August 2009, Joanna Michael from Cardiff called 999 and told the call handler her ex-boyfriend had been to her house and hit her. He left, threatening to come back and kill her. The call operator mistakenly heard that he had threatened to ‘hit’ her. Because the call had gone through to the wrong police service initially, when it was passed to South Wales Police, they did not get the full story and they did not grade the call as immediately urgent. By the time the police arrived at Joanna’s house, she was dead.

Unfortunately, the circumstances of Joanna’s death are not unusual. Two women a week on average are murdered by their partner or former partner. But it has never been so obvious as it was in Joanna’s case that the police could do more. Joanna’s family, with the support of Welsh Women’s Aid, went to court and argued that the police had been negligent in failing to respond to her 999 call, and that their failure had breached Joanna’s right to life under Article 2 of the Human Rights Act.

Why it's the Human Rights Act that makes accountability possible

Negligence actions against the police traditionally do not succeed in English and Welsh law. This case was no different – the Supreme Court did not allow the argument that the police had been negligent because it would leave the police open to claims from everybody who calls 999 and would make policing more difficult. One of the judges, Lady Hale disagreed. She hoped that finding liability in negligence would lead to “much-needed improvements in their response to threats of serious domestic abuse”.

Although the negligence action was not successful, the Court allowed the claim to proceed on the human rights grounds. This is because, under the Human Rights Act, the police owed Joanna a positive duty to protect her life (Article 2). Whether or not they had breached that duty was a question of fact and should proceed to trial.

Why is this so important?

Speaking about the case, Eleri Butler, CEO of Welsh Women’s Aid says:
Where there are failings in protecting victims of domestic violence, accountability is crucial. Violence against women is a fundamental violation of women’s human rights and the Supreme Court’s judgment provides timely reaffirmation of the importance of human rights protections for victims of domestic violence. The Human Rights Act has a vital role to play in this.  If it was not for the Human Rights Act, the family of Joanna Michael would have no prospect of obtaining accountability for Joanna’s death.
This case makes it clear that domestic violence is a human rights issue. The highest court in our land has made it clear that the police have a legal duty to victims of domestic violence to take steps to protect when a woman’s right to life is at risk. When Joanna’s case goes to trial the judge will decide whether or not the police did all they could reasonably do to protect Joanna’s life.

The Human Rights Act made it possible for Joanna’s family to directly challenge actions of the police that may have led to her death. If the police did breach Joanna’s right to life then South Wales Police, and police forces across Britain, will have to take steps to ensure victims of domestic violence are not failed in the same way ever again.

Preventing violence against women in Wales

The Joanna Michael case put domestic violence on the agenda in Wales. On Tuesday 10 March, the Welsh Assembly will hear the Stage 4 debate of the Violence Against Women (Wales) Bill. If made law; this Bill would secure vital protections for women and girls in Wales, including a whole school approach to education on violence against women in schools. The Bill passing is not a sure thing, so Welsh Women’s Aid are asking you to show your support by tweeting #cantlosethebill and helping to ensure that domestic violence is stopped before it can start. Find out more about the Bill here.

Protecting the human rights of women in the UK

With domestic violence squarely on the human rights agenda, on International Women’s Day we can reflect on the ways the Human Rights Act protects the rights of women here in the UK. Along with victims of domestic violence, the Human Rights Act has held the police to account for failing victims of rape. No other piece of law can protect women’s rights the same way. The Joanna Michael case shows that if it is a question of police negligence, the common law will not hold the police to account for failings.

Not only does the Human Rights Act allow us to hold public authorities to account, it is also a tool for ensuring that services are delivered in a way that respects rights in the first place. All public authorities must deliver services and make decisions in a way that respects human rights. Now that this case has made sure that failings towards victims of domestic violence are seen as a human rights issue, the police and public authorities will need to examine their services and ensure that these failings do not happen again. BIHR’s work helping public services to embed human rights in their work shows that this is achievable and leads to better outcomes for services and service users in the long term. Read more about the people whose lives have changed through our work on the Human Rights Act.

Speaking up for human rights at home 

If you think human rights are worth respecting and protecting, consider joining in with March For Human Rights, BIHR’s month of activities helping people to speak up. Check out our mini-site and tweet us a selfie with the hashtag #ImAlrightWithHumanRights, letting us know why you are alright with human rights, especially this International Women’s Day.  

Back to top

Showing 10 of 0

Latest

  • The Rights Removal Bill: Resource for Public Officials

    The Rights Removal Bill: Resource for Public Officials

    Find out what the impact of the Rights Removal Bill will be on public officials, and they can do to protect our Human Rights Act

  • The Rights Removal Bill: What's the latest?

    The Rights Removal Bill: What's the latest?

    Find out what stage the Rights Removal Bill is at as it progresses through Parliament.

  • BIHR and Sheffield Health & Social Care NHS Foundation Trust

    BIHR and Sheffield Health & Social Care NHS Foundation Trust

    Find out about our human rights learning programme with Sheffield Health & Social Care NHS Foundation Trust!

  • Weekly Human Rights News: 12 August 2022

    Weekly Human Rights News: 12 August 2022

    This week's news includes an opportunity to join the BIHR team and our latest vlog.

Most read

  • The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide

    The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide

    The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide

  • A. The Law: The Human Rights Act

    A. The Law: The Human Rights Act

    Find out about our law here at home, the Human Rights Act, and how it protects us all.

  • Abolition of the Death Penalty

    Abolition of the Death Penalty

    Abolition of the Death Penalty

  • Social Justice and Human Rights

    Social Justice and Human Rights

    This World Social Justice Day we look at how we can use Human Rights to achieve positive social change.

  • What Rights Do I Have?

    What Rights Do I Have?

    What rights do I have?

  • The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide for staff working in public bodies

    The Covid-19 Vaccine and Human Rights: A short guide for staff working in public bodies

    Read our short guide for staff working in public bodies about the Covid-19 vaccine and human rights

  • The Human Rights Act

    The Human Rights Act

    Find out more about the Human Rights Act, the main law that protects our human rights across the UK.

  • B. The European Convention on Human Rights

    B. The European Convention on Human Rights

    Find out about the European Convention on Human Rights and what it means for you.

  • The history of human rights

    Did you know the ideas behind human rights in the UK are over 800 years old? Read more about the journey behind the Human Rights Act.

  • Volunteer and Fundraise

    Volunteer and Fundraise

    volunteering opportunities

Tag cloud

capacity dignity European Convention on Human Rights General Election 2017 Government health Health and Human Rights Health and Social Care Healthcare human rights Human Rights Act International human rights Justice Mental Health older people social care

Latest tweet

Keep in touch

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER LIKE US ON FACEBOOK WATCH US ON YOUTUBE

Helpful Links

  • My Human Rights
  • Human Rights Training
  • Easy Read Human Rights Info
  • BIHR Blog
  • Become a Friend of BIHR

Please note the British Institute of Human Rights does not provide advice, help can be found here

Our office can be contacted on 020 3039 3646
For press enquiries please call 020 3039 3646 or email [email protected]

EMAIL US

The British Institute of Human Rights is a registered charity (1101575) and registered company (4978121)

Correspondence and registered office address: BIHR, c/o Lewis & Co Chartered Accountants, 8 Coldbath Square, London, EC1R 5HL
Please note that we do not work at this address and the office here is not open to visitors; the address is for correspondence only.
Please therefore contact us by phone (020 3039 3646) if you wish to speak to us, but keep in mind that we do not provide advice;
help can be found here.