Chapter 2: How do human rights work – the legal overview

There are three layers of human rights protection in the UK – domestic, regional and international. These are enforced and monitored in different ways.

Human Rights legal overview

2.1 The Human Rights Act and the European Convention on Human Rights

The Human Rights Act came into force in the UK on 2 October 2000. The Act brings most of the rights contained in the European Convention on Human Rights into UK law. The European Convention on Human Rights, which UK lawyers and civil servants helped to draft, was agreed in 1950 by the Council of Europe. The UK signed up to this Convention in 1951. The list of the rights it contains can be found here.

Key things you need to know about the Human Rights Act:

  • The Human Rights Act places all public authorities in the UK, such as NHS Trusts, local authorities and central government departments, under a duty to respect the rights it contains in everything that they do.

    What is a public authority?

    Reveal practical exercise: what is a public authority?

    Who is actually covered by the term public authority? Move over the boxes below and see if you can work out which organisations are public authorities.

    National Health Service

    National Health Service

    National Health Service

    Yes! One of the most obvious ones on the list.

    Supermarkets

    Supermarkets

    Supermarkets

    Nope! Food may be essential, but selling it doesn’t count as a public service.

    The Police

    The Police

    Yes! Police uphold and enforce the laws of the state.

    Transport for London

    Transport for London

    Transport for London

    Yes! Keeping London’s transport service moving is no private task – especially in a city of over 7.5 million people!

    Banks

    Banks

    Banks

    Nope! While the bank bailouts may confuse this option, banks are definitely private organisations.

    Private residential care homes

    Private residential care homes

    Private residential care homes

    It depends… If the service provided by the care home is state-funded then Yes! If the care home is purely private then Nope!

    State Schools

    State Schools

    State Schools

    Yes! State schools perform a public service by providing free education for all.

    National Newspapers

    National Newspapers

    National Newspapers

    Nope! National media newspapers pride themselves on their distinct separation from the organs of state power.

    You

    You

    You

    Do you perform a public service on behalf of the state? If you answered yes then you have duties under the Human Rights Act 1998!

  • The Human Rights Act makes it possible for individuals to bring human rights cases in ordinary UK courts and tribunals
  • Before this, you had to go to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg to claim your rights
  • You can still take a case to the European Court, but now that the Human Rights Act is in force your case has to go through the UK courts first
  • All laws in the UK have to be interpreted and applied in a way that fits with the Human Rights Act (as far as possible)

These points are covered in more detail in our factsheet on ‘How the Human Rights Act works’.

It’s also very important to remember that the Human Rights Act is not just about the law and taking cases to court. As the later chapters in this toolkit demonstrate, the Act is relevant to many of the decisions people make and the situations people experience on a daily basis. We hope the toolkit will encourage you to use the Human Rights Act ‘beyond the courtroom’ in your advocacy for individuals and in your wider campaigning and lobbying work.

2.2 The UN human rights treaties

The UK has signed up to a series of international human rights treaties (also called Conventions or Covenants) agreed by the United Nations. These treaties place legal obligations on the states that sign up to them, in contrast to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights which is not a legally binding document. The text of these treaties can be found on the website of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.

Key things you need to know about the UN human rights treaties:

  • There are nine core UN human rights treaties
  • They cover a range of issues and groups including torture, women and racial discrimination
  • They cover a broader range of rights than the Human Rights Act and European Convention
  • Each treaty is monitored and enforced by an expert UN committee through a state reporting system, individual complaints mechanisms and general comments
  • You cannot bring a case in the UK courts against the Government using one of these treaties as they are not part of UK law
  • However, they can act as very powerful campaigning tools

You can find out more about the UN human rights treaties by downloading our factsheet on the international human rights system.

2.3. Different laws, different rights

As you’ll have seen from the above, one of the key differences between the different human rights laws is the way they are monitored and enforced. Another important difference is the rights they contain.

Practical exercise

As explained earlier, the Human Rights Act and the European Convention on Human Rights contain virtually the same set of rights. However, now compare the list of rights contained in the European Convention with the rights contained in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (it might be easiest if you print them out).

Do you notice any differences? Do you think there are any important rights that are left out of the European Convention?

You will probably have noticed that the list of rights in the European Convention is much smaller than the UDHR. You may have also noticed that a number of rights that are missing are related to economic and social issues, such as the right to health and the right to a minimum standard of living. This is currently a gap in our human rights protection. However, some of the rights contained in the European Convention, such as the right to respect for private and family life, can still be used to tackle everyday economic and social issues.

Since the rights contained in the European Convention are enforceable in the UK courts through the Human Rights Act, these are the rights that voluntary and community sector organisations can currently use most directly in their work, particularly with regards to advocacy. Therefore, the next two chapters focus on some of these rights in more detail. However, it is important to remember that at an international level there is a more widely recognised set of rights that provide a wide range of exciting campaigning and lobbying opportunities.

Before moving on to the next section, test your knowledge so far with our human rights quiz.